Edward Fennell’s LEGAL DIARY
Diary news plus insights, commentary and appointments from the legal world
17 July 2026
Editorial contact: fennell.edward@yahoo.com
SHORT THOUGHT FOR THE WEEK:
The Shame of It All
Andy Burnham arrives as Prime Minister on Monday without a mandate for his political agenda. Whatever that agenda might include, however, the claim is that it will be ‘unashamedly Labour’. The implication being, presumably, that Starmer was ‘ashamedly Labour’ which was why he did not do enough to tax the rich. Hence a wealth tax was now on the agenda – possibly.
Robert Brodrick, Private client partner at Payne Hicks Beach, has a word of warning for Burnham.
“This uncertainty risks changing behaviour before anything has even happened,” says Brodrick. “Extreme tax changes can cause individuals to leave the UK unwillingly, and can create paralysis if people are unwilling to deploy capital because of upfront tax costs.
“If the new Prime Minister is serious about economic renewal, the focus should be on policies that reward long-term investment in businesses, including from foreign investors. He should also be encouraging wealthy individuals based abroad to come here on a favourable regime for more than just four years. That would bring spending and investment into the UK and help put the UK back on the map as a leading destination for business.“
Starmer’s first and immediate error was the penalisation of the elderly poor. Burnham may make the error in the other direction. Where ‘true Labour’ – shamed or unashamed – stands on this is anyone’s guess.
The LegalDiarist
In this edition
+ LEGAL DIARY OF THE WEEK
“On ‘is ‘ead, mate”
AI in the Witness Box?
Vegans’ Rights Confirmed
Let’s Do It Again, Says Browne Jacobson
+ CONTRIBUTED ARTICLES OF THE WEEK
Highlights and Implications of the UK Corporate Plan for the UKIPO by Jim Bell and Craig Slater
Implications of the Government’s new ‘right to work’ reforms by Oliver O’Sullivan
+ LEGAL COMMENT OF THE WEEK
on fraud in the digital age, proposed social media curfew, more investment in legal aid, advertising of junk food, access to legal aid and data breach at Quantas
+ APPOINTMENTS OF THE WEEK
at MICHELMORES
LEGAL DIARY OF THE WEEK
“On ‘is ‘ead, mate”
England supporters watching the recent Wolrd Cup game against Argentina will have had different ways of dealing with the painfully horrible result. One person well known to the Legal Diarist turned off the TV immediately after the final whistle and went for a long, long walk. However Jeremy Berg, a Litigation partner with Spencer West LLP, put the occasion to more positive use. He analysed the outcome from a legal perspective and reached the conclusion that the match ‘offered a masterclass in the perils of “defensive litigation”and the transformative power of a pro-active, assertive approach’.
Argentina manager Lionel Scaloni, Berg explained, never abandoned his objective even when behind. “[He] kept their shape, rotated their players, and continued to probe, as England retreated. Scaloni did not play for a draw; he managed the game as if the victory was still there to be won.”
Litigators should follow the same model. “A proactive strategy does not mean being reckless; it means maintaining a constant, calculated offensive pressure. You continue to press your advantage and seeking disclosure for the purpose of building the narrative of your case.”
If Thomas Tuchel gets the sack maybe the FA should replace him with a successful litigator instead. After all, kicking a ball can’t be that difficult – it’s the strategy which scores.
AI in the Witness Box?
It was bound to happen but is it happening too soon and without guardrails? The Home Office has announced that AI will be used by police officers to review and summarise evidence . The ambition is valid – to free the police from being bogged down in paperwork and allow them to spend more time tackling crime on the streets. But are we confident that the AI is yet up to ‘the job’?
Rebecca Smart, a Criminal Lawyer at Payne Hicks Beach has her reservations.“There is an obvious attraction in using AI to assist police with disclosure,” she says. “Modern investigations generate vast quantities of digital material, including phones, emails, messages, videos and cloud storage, and disclosure failures already cause delay, wasted resources and abandoned trials.”
Amidst so much available material there is a real possibility of overlooking some small but vital piece of evidence. Totally reliable technology would be an amazing boon to detection. But have we reached that stage yet?
“That creates a significant fair-trial concern,” says Smart. “The defence is entitled to know whether the prosecution has identified material that may undermine its case or assist the accused; if an algorithm wrongly filters, ranks, summarises or omits material, the defence may never know what has been missed. AI systems can hallucinate, misclassify context, reproduce bias, or give an apparently authoritative answer without explaining the reasoning or source material behind it. In court, the question will then become who is responsible: the officer who relied on the tool, the force that procured it, the developer that built it, or the prosecution that served the disclosure schedule. Unless accountability is clear, there is a danger of a “computer says no” culture in which flawed automated outputs are treated as neutral and unchallengeable. In that scenario, speed and productivity would come at the expense of the accused’s ability to test the evidence, challenge the prosecution case and receive a fair trial.”
Rebecca Smart’s concerns are shared by criminal barrister Rose Burns of 12CP.“I’m sorry to say that I am reluctant to accept that AI can improve criminal investigations or evidence gathering,” she says. “Clearly it’s early days but I’m not convinced of its usefulness in a world where “Justice is truth in action”, to quote Benjamin Disraeli. There is too much room for error, with catastrophic results in terms of people’s lives and liberty. And might it discount the human element when casting its robotic eye over the available evidence – or manipulate the evidence to suit the user’s agenda?”
Vegans’ Rights Confirmed
How far should ‘freedom of conscience’ go when it comes to one’s choice of diet? A lot of ‘street food’ these days in Britain seems to be verging on the edge of criminal (and might actually be so) but should someone in gaol be entitled to demand it as of right?
Or, alternatively, as in the case of Switzerland should vegans have a right to their preferences when under the care of the state.
Earlier this week the European Court of Human Rights decided that Switzerland had violated the rights of two vegan applicants after their requests for vegan food were not properly examined while they had been incarcerated (one in a psychiatric hospital).
Hence there had been breaches of Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights (which protects freedom of thought, conscience and religion) and Article 13, the right to an effective remedy.
The Vegan Society and members of The Vegan Society’s International Rights Network, led by Vegan Rights Advocate, Dr. Jeanette Rowley, played a part in the case having been permitted to intervene as third parties offering technical advice on veganism.
“We are grateful to have been able to assist the Court,” said Dr. Rowley. “This is a significant and important judgment that builds on earlier Strasbourg recognition of vegan convictions. The Court has recognised that the convictions of vegans deserve the same seriousness and respect as other protected beliefs under human rights law.
“When someone is detained, hospitalised or otherwise dependent on public authorities for food, veganism cannot be brushed aside as a mere lifestyle or dietary choice. Authorities must take vegan convictions seriously, examine requests for vegan food properly and provide effective remedies.”
Famously, Nazi Germany’s Minister of Propaganda Joseph Goebbels heavily promoted Hitler as a strict vegetarian so it should not be too surprising that veggies can end up as gaol birds.
Let’s Do It Again, Says Browne Jacobson
Winning awards twice in a row is always doubly satisfying as can be evidenced by the team players at Browne Jacobson who last week were awarded the Employer of the Year title at the 2026 UpReach Student Social Mobility Award thus repeating their success of last year.
“What makes this recognition so meaningful is that it is not built on one initiative or one moment in time, but the result of years of listening, learning and committing to taking action and doing things differently,” said Tom Lyas, Head of Resourcing and Social Mobility at the firm.
“From the purposeful way we design our programmes to the inclusive way we recruit, we are constantly asking where else we can improve, which reflects our desire to be at the forefront of tackling society’s biggest issues. The aspiring professionals we work with deserve our very best efforts; and that’s what continues to motivate our team and our colleagues every single day.
“The data shows that when you remove barriers and provide people with a genuine opportunity, they thrive. We are always looking at how we can go further, help more people fulfil their potential, and make a lasting difference to the profession.”
In fact the firm has quite a record in this area having topped the Social Mobility Foundation’s Employer Index in four of the past five years and being the highest ranked law firm in the Index for five years running.
The driver for the firm’s serial success is the area of social mobility work is its FAIRE initiative (Fairer Access into Real Experience), which has engaged more than 88,000 young people with virtual and in-person events and work experience programmes since launching in 2019. “Winning this award for the second consecutive year is a reminder of how far we have come, but more importantly, it reminds us how much further we want to go,” commented Victoria Howard, Senior Social Mobility Inclusion Manager.
CONTRIBUTED ARTICLES OF THE WEEK
Highlights and Implications of the UK Corporate Plan for the UKIPO
by Jim Bell and Craig Slater
The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) Corporate Plan 2026–2027 signals a pivotal phase in the evolution of the UK IP system, with implications for innovators, legal practitioners, and commercial enterprises marks a key stage in the UK IP system. As the final year of the 2024–2027 strategy, the plan emphasises delivery, modernisation, and adaptation to emerging technologies—particularly artificial intelligence (AI)—while maintaining a robust and trusted IP framework.

A central pillar of the plan is the accelerated digital transformation of IP services through the “One IPO” programme. The transition to integrated, end‑to‑end digital systems for patents and trade marks is intended to enhance efficiency, reduce administrative burdens, and improve user experience. For stakeholders, this should translate into more streamlined filing and portfolio management processes. However, the plan acknowledges that in the short term, transitional challenges are likely to result, possibly leading to delays. Practitioners and administrators particularly are urged to maintain increased procedural vigilance during this transitionPractitioners should remain vigilant during the transitional period.
AI within the IP system, both operationally and substantively, forms another pillar of the plan. The IPO’s commitment to adopting AI tools to improve operationsexamination processes, customer service, and publicly available information reflects a broader shift towards automation in IP administration. More importantly, ongoing policy work concerning AI and copyright underscores the UK’s attempt to balance innovation with rights protection. This suggests that the legal framework governing AI-generated works and use of copyrighted information will remain in flux. While this may result in some level of uncertainty for many stakeholders, oOpportunities and challenges for copyright holders and developers of technology are likely to arise, and the prudent practitioner will be ready to advise as the challenges appear.

The plan also intends to render the IP system more accessible to entities with limited legal budgets, such as small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs). By promoting IP‑backed financing and improving awareness of IP valuation, the UKIPO places IP rights as central to business growth and investment strategies. The UKIPO also plans to expand guidance and training to improve IP literacyFurther, the UKIPO intends to expand guidance, training, and support programmes to improve IP literacy among those lacking the necessary knowledge. From a practitioner’s standpoint, this should lead to greater demand for services such as IP evaluation, strategic portfolio management, and IP procurement strategic IP support, allowing IP professionals to expand their advisory role.
Policy reform will continue as part of the plan, particularly regarding standard essential patents (SEPs), design law, and enforcement against infringement. These reforms are intended to ensure that the UK IP framework remains internationally competitive and and adaptable.responsive to technological change in the global economy Enhanced enforcement measures and the development of a clearer evidence base for IP crime further suggest a more proactive regulatory environment, providing additional opportunities for practitioners to assist their clients in navigating reforms..
Overall, the corporate plan points to a UK IP system that is becoming more digital, data‑driven, and economically integrated, while actively adapting to the challenges and benefits presented by AI and global competition.. For stakeholders, the overall implications are improved accessibility and strategic opportunities in the long term, coupled with short‑term complexity as reforms and new technologies are implemented.
Jim Bell is a Partner and Craig Slater an Associate at Finnegan
Implications of the Government’s new ‘right to work’ reforms
by Oliver O’Sullivan
Finally, changes to the UK’s illegal working regime, approved under the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, are expected to come into force on 1 October 2026. Following seven months of consultation with businesses and other stakeholders, the Home Office published its findings on 30 June 2026, confirming plans to extend right to work requirements beyond direct employees to include contractors, freelancers, gig workers and subcontractors.
Supporters of the reforms argue they close a significant gap in the current system. Under existing rules, employers can face substantial civil penalties and potential criminal liability for employing someone without the right to work. However, where labour is supplied through contractors or several layers of subcontracting, responsibility can become diluted, allowing organisations that ultimately benefit from the work to avoid direct liability. The new framework is intended to ensure organisations cannot sidestep compliance obligations simply by outsourcing labour.
Published illegal working penalty data suggests illegal working is most commonly identified in sectors such as nail bars, fast-food outlets and car washes, where informal or cash-based arrangements can make employment relationships difficult to trace. In many cases, workers may receive payment with little formal documentation, making it challenging to establish where responsibility sits within the labour supply chain.
The reforms are also likely to have significant implications for gig-economy companies. To date, major food delivery and taxi companies have generally avoided illegal working penalties by maintaining that they act as intermediaries connecting consumers with service providers. The extension of right to work obligations will require much greater oversight of the individuals delivering services on their behalf, creating increased accountability for ensuring drivers and riders have the legal right to work in the UK.
These changes will create new compliance challenges for sectors that rely heavily on contracting and subcontracting, including construction and engineering. Many businesses operate with relatively small permanent workforces and scale up through extensive contractor networks depending on project requirements. Under the new rules, organisations at the top of the supply chain will need visibility over everyone engaged on a contract and will be responsible for ensuring right to work checks are completed throughout the workforce.
This might then prevent some illegal working in these sectors. Since around 90% of working-age Britons possess a valid passport, the issue shouldn’t be that these workers cannot evidence their right to work. The issue is more likely to be larger organisations centralising visibility of their contracts and all the workers engaged and manage the planning of completing the right to work process prior to the contract commencing.
Oliver O’Sullivan is Director of Immigration at Migrate UK
LEGAL COMMENT OF THE WEEK
TOPIC: The publication of the review ‘Fraud in the Digital Age’ by Jonathan Fisher KC
COMMENT BY: Louise Hodges, Partner, Criminal Litigation, Kingsley Napley
“The Fisher Review does not pull its punches. With only 1% of reported fraud cases resulting in a criminal justice outcome, and victims waiting nearly 18 months for a charging decision, Jonathan Fisher KC concludes that the era of tolerating latitude towards fraud must end. His 47 recommendations represent a comprehensive and serious attempt to shift the dial – from the way online platforms are held to account, to whistleblowing incentives and protections, to increasing the maximum sentence for the most serious fraud offenders to 20 years. Whether the government has the ambition to match that seriousness with action and what priority the incoming administration will put on tackling fraud will be interesting to see. The publication of this Part 2 of Fisher’s report (focusing on fraud offences) came on the same day that the government published its response to Part 1 and the Leveson Review recommendations dealing with disclosure. It looks like there could be some significant changes coming down the track even if only some of the recommendations are adopted. “
TOPIC: The likelihood that 16 and 17-year-olds will face a voluntary overnight social media curfew along with the shut-down of infinite scrolling and breaks in AI chatbot use under plans announced by Technology Secretary Liz Kendall.
COMMENT BY: Mark Jones, Online Safety Act expert and Criminal Partner
“The Government’s response feels like a scattergun approach. Restricting infinite scrolling overnight is only one small part of a much bigger picture. Platforms also rely on push notifications, variable reward systems through likes and shares and other behavioural design techniques that encourage compulsive use and keep young people coming back.
“If these measures focus on limiting when 16 and 17-year-olds can use social media, rather than requiring platforms to fundamentally change the way they design and promote content, they’re treating the symptoms rather than the cause. Restrictions often encourage workarounds, whether that’s VPNs, alternate accounts or other creative ways of bypassing them.
“The real issue is platform accountability. Unless Government addresses the other addictive design features and the harmful content these algorithms continue to amplify, these reforms fall short of being a meaningful overhaul of online safety.”
TOPIC: The Government announces more investment in legal aid
COMMENT BY: Carrie Laws, Director at The Family Law Company
“We welcome any investment that helps victims get swifter justice, and the enhanced fees for barristers in rape and serious sexual offence cases are a step in the right direction. However, the package doesn’t cover family legal aid, including funding for victims of domestic abuse navigating the family courts and those having to go through the family justice system to be able to spend time with their children.
“Our entire team is trained in the domestic abuse, stalking and honour-based violence (DASH) risk assessment, because so much of our legal aid work involves exactly these cases. A victim’s route through the family courts – getting a non-molestation order, resolving arrangements for children (including who they live with and who they spend time with), separating finances from an abusive partner – often runs parallel to a criminal case, sometimes for years. If the criminal side moves faster but the family side is still under-resourced, victims can end up protected in one court and almost entirely unsupported in the other.
“It’s not just victims of domestic abuse who suffer because of the lack of legal aid. Family legal aid eligibility for divorce and child arrangements has narrowed steadily and significantly since 2013, and in most cases now, gateway evidence of domestic abuse is the only route in. While that’s an important safeguard, it also means the system depends entirely on firms like ours continuing to do this work even when legal aid fees haven’t kept pace. The family legal aid means assessment (used for all divorce and child arrangements matters) is based on figures established 30 years ago when the cost of living was considerably lower. They haven’t even raised in line with inflation so that means that there are many people (predominantly women) living in poverty who are assessed as financially ineligible for legal aid. If the Government is serious about halving violence against women and girls within a decade, family legal aid urgently needs the same attention as the criminal courts are getting today.”
TOPIC: The proposal by the Health and Social Care Committee for a ban on all outdoor advertising of junk food and mandatory front-of-pack labelling to tackle obesity levels in England together with a number of other measures intended to curb obesity including the mandatory reporting and targets for supermarkets, backed up with penalties, on the amount of healthy food they sell
COMMENT BY: George McLellan, Disputes Partner, Sharpe Pritchard
“UK public health officials and regulators have been actively imposing new and increasingly onerous rules on food businesses for decades now. Their promise is always that their latest interventions will reduce obesity and save the NHS money, and yet obesity rates have not fallen, and the NHS hasn’t saved a penny. All these interventions have done in practice is to increase costs for businesses and inflate grocery prices for consumers. Imposing even more red tape on businesses will not make a positive difference to public health.”
.
TOPIC: The publication of the Justice Committee’s report into access to justice and legal aid
COMMENT BY: Sara Fowler, President, CILEX (Chartered Institute of Legal Executives)
“The crisis in legal aid has been apparent for many years, with a lack of investment in our justice system seeing increases in those unable to access legal representation and a steady decline in the number of providers available to take on legal aid work.
This report should act as a wake-up call to the government. Access to justice for all is a fundamental aspect of our democracy and as it stands, legal aid provision is falling well short of delivering that.
The report rightly recommends that means tested legal aid thresholds rise in line with inflation, alongside the introduction of an independent mechanism to review legal aid in line with average incomes and rates of self-representation.
In many cases, people need access to legal representation in their local area and remote advice should not be used to substitute local face-to-face services – justice cannot be done on the cheap.
The potential for miscarriages of justice due to a lack of representation in the criminal justice system is of particular concern. We hope that by the highlighting the current state of the duty lawyers scheme – which the report stated has seen the number of duty lawyers fall by 25% over the last nine years, with few younger lawyers joining their ranks – will act as a catalyst to removing barriers to suitably qualified CILEX Lawyers taking up those roles in their own right.”
TOPIC: The announcement by Australia’s Privacy Commissioner that a tech support scam was the cause of the massive 2025 data breach at Australian airline Qantas and found the carrier didn’t breach its privacy obligations despite leaking personally identifiable information for 5.7 million customers
COMMENT BY: Dr. Ilia Kolochenko, founder ImmuniWeb and lawyer practicing in cybersecurity and data protection
“From the legal viewpoint, the liability of impersonated company is largely uncertain, jurisdiction specific, and is deeply intertwined with the facts and security measures implemented by the victimized company. From the technical viewpoint, preventive monitoring, customer education and ongoing awareness campaigns can greatly help to reduce the impact of AI-powered fraud.
In 2026, we will probably see another surge of AI-propelled fraud. Indeed, the next 18 months are poised to bring record revenues to cybercriminals and gigantic losses to businesses and consumers. While human error remains among the most prevalent root causes of security incidents, the attackers, even the technically unskilled ones, now have access to powerful LLM models that can artfully deceive and impersonate by text, voice, images and even video.
The problem is that while Western AI companies continually harden and improve the guardrails to prevent their AI models from misbehaving or giving harmful advice, most other AI vendors do not care and release AI models without any guardrails into the wild. Resultingly, scammers and fraudsters can easily impersonate anyone or anything. Even experienced cybersecurity professionals fall victim to synthetic content when the latter combines psychological tricks that modern AI masters pretty well. This is why strict regulation of AI in the EU or US will unlikely bring major results: cybercriminals will simply shift to foreign and open-sourced AI models.”
LEGAL SECTOR APPOINTMENTS OF THE WEEK
MICHELMORES

Charlotte Davies has been appointed to the newly-created role of Head of Knowledge & Innovation at Michelmores with a view to her leading the next phase of the firm’s knowledge, innovation and AI strategy. Previously at Greenwoods, where she led the knowledge management function, Davies has more than a decade of experience as a practising employment lawyer alongside extensive leadership in knowledge, legal technology and organisational transformation.
As the firm describes it, the new role ‘sits at the intersection of legal expertise, technology and client service’. As AI rapidly reshapes the legal profession, Michelmores says it is investing in the capabilities needed to ensure its lawyers have ‘immediate access to the firm’s collective knowledge, can adopt new technologies with confidence and continue to innovate in the way legal services are delivered’.
“Knowledge has become one of the Firm’s most strategic assets,” comments the Michelmores’ Managing Partner, Tim Richards. “The businesses that succeed over the next decade will be those that combine exceptional legal expertise with the ability to learn faster, innovate continuously and harness technology intelligently. Charlotte brings exactly the leadership we need as we continue to evolve how we work with our clients and support our lawyers.”
We hope that you’ve been interested or amused by something in this week’s LEGAL DIARY. If so do send on to colleagues.
And please continue sending your ‘Diary-type’ stories, insights legal comment and appointments to
fennell.edward@yahoo.com